I was just caught in an argument between two friends over generative AI. One friend is an aspiring singer who supports herself through low-paying delivery gig work. She recently used AI to generate cover artwork for her new album. When my other friend, who is a successful DJ, found out, he reacted angrily, saying that she should have employed an illustrator or photographer. I sympathize with my musician friend. On the other hand, I’m aware of all the other negative impacts of AI (water use, exploiting labour in the Global South etc). Is it ever acceptable for a low-income creative to use generative AI in this way, even though it takes away jobs from other creatives also trying to make a living?

Stuck of Saarbrücken